Dude Weather Subscribe to Secrets Minneapolis / St. Paul

Defenestrator

Delegate Gone Wild

Share

Photo by Jeff Lennan

It seems like only yesterday that Saint Paul was flooded with hordes of conservatives looking for nothing more than to have a swingin' good time with likeminded people and the occasional (and possibly fictitious) woman with loose morals and an eye for fine timepieces. Not to mention the roving packs of skinny white kids hell-bent on railing against the injustices of the world, some of whom spoiled the party for everyone by lobbing homemade explosives and assorted forms of human waste at police and delegates, who responded to such acts with a decidedly Republican show of force. After all, nothing kills a party like a twenty-something armed with the high explosive equivalent of flaming bags of dog crap.

But despite the sensationalistic headlines and the locust swarm of citizen journalists searching the non-Euclidean urban geometries of St. Paul for the stories that even the all-seeing eye of Jason DeRusha missed, there were stories yet to be unearthed - one of which involved profound idiocy by a candidate for higher office right here in the Twin Cities. And while idiocy and profound ignorance of the social mores the common man lives by is all too common among politicians, allowing it to go on without a rolled-up newspaper to the nose is unacceptable.

Like many, Jeff Grubler was in town to protest at the RNC. Performing skits and songs like "Insane in the McCain Brain" and "Bomb Iran" outside the cordoned off convention area while wearing cardboard McCain and Bush masks, protestors and delegates described the show as "mesmerizing." Renato D'Amico, an alternate McCain delegate from Massachusetts, called the show "nice and innocent." Of course, Ed Matthews, Republican Congressional candidate for the 4th District, who happened to be passing by on his way to the Xcel Center, didn't see it quite the same way. The masks Grubler and his fellow actors were using were made out of one of Matthews' campaign signs.

According to Matthews, he walked up to Grubler after the performance was done and asked to see his mask, which Grubler handed over for inspection. Matthews says that Grubler then "took a swing at me and ripped off my credentials," at which point he was tackled by the assorted security forces assembled at the gate. When we asked Matthews why he didn't press charges against such an obviously dangerous and unhinged minstrel, the likes of whom the world has not seen since Sir Robin himself set bravely forth from Camelot, Matthews responded that, "I just want to let bygones be bygones. I think it's pretty big of me."

Of course, several witnesses who managed to tear their eyes away from a passing Jon Voight saw the scene differently.

D'Amico, the alternate Republican delegate from Massachusetts, and Amy Waksmonski, a local videographer on hand to document the RNC, both say that, after noticing the masks were made from his signs, Matthews started shouting, "That's mine! That's my sign," while attempting to rip the mask off Grubler's face. A titanic struggle between two middle-class white men ensued, with Matthews taking the mask and Grubler managing to take possession of Matthews' delegate credentials.

Predictably, things went south for Grubler from there, the police taking him into custody while Matthews was escorted into the Xcel with no repercussions whatsoever. Other witnesses to the incident, including the Oklahoma delegates in the video of the event's aftermath, seemed to take Matthews' free pass quite poorly -- several railing against the apparent lack of respect for free speech rights and little to no interest in what Matthews may have done to instigate the situation.

In any case, let us forget, for a moment, the fact that the police never interviewed witnesses or attempted to determine the truth of what happened before carting Grubler off in handcuffs. Let's ignore the lack of an official police report on the event, not to mention the SPPD and Capitol Police's unwillingness to discuss any of the details of the incident. Instead let us focus simply on the painful notion that, should these eyewitness accounts be true, we'll have yet another reason for the nation's profound lack of confidence in our Congress. Not to mention yet another asshat living among us.

Of course, Saint Paul has about as much chance of voting Republican as Matthews does of finding himself the Republican meat in a freaky left-leaning sandwich with German Chancellor Angela Merkel and Megan Fox. So, for the moment it would seem we're safe from the legislative tentacles of a politician who by several accounts, like so many toddlers faced with the prospect of not getting a toy at Target, forgets to use his words when he wants something.

8 Reader Comments

Anonymous (not verified)08:26am
Sep 25
So, it would appear that taking, destroying and using others' property (without permission) is now under protection of free speech? If what you report is true and the masks in question were the property of Matthews and not used with his permission then this would by definition be theft, regardless of use. However, the way in which you report the story in this measure; I am in my rights to take your property and do with it as I please in the name of 'freedom of speech and freedom of expression'. I do agree, there seem to be two stories. And yes it appears that police favored one side over the other. Don't twist things here - I agree rights may have been/were violated or ignored altogether. Yet rights are not rights when they impede on the rights of others. And it is a shame that the actions of the few disrupted the noted peaceful right of the many that were here in MN. Yet I can not fathom that theft is a right given to anyone (though some would say it is 'taken' - no pun intended). Oh, and if you are not focusing on something - you sure bring it to the fore in an unflinching manner. Let's not focus on how you are unbalanced or how you sink to the level of those you deride by calling them an "asshat". I am confused as to whether this is a news article or an OP/ED article. But if it is 'news', I would say, I think not. This is sensationalist, propagandist, agenda driven opinion that is laced with something of an actual event or occurrence. If you fancy yourself a journalist - you should remove your bias and opinion from the article. If this is OP/ED then I agree with anyone who states that you are totally entitled to all the favoritism and opinion you note here.
Anonymous (not verified)08:32am
Sep 25
Follow up (same person here): Your page now showed up with its title and I notice it is a blog. My previous post was from arriving at your site from a news site - noting this page as news and not OP/ED (or blog). I now understand this is not news. Carry on!
Rich Goldsmith11:53am
Sep 25
Which news site provided the link, if I may ask?
Jill Yablonski08:42am
Sep 25
Just to be clear: the signs were only Matthews' "property" in the sense that they had been fashioned from lawn signs used during his campaign. They were not personal property that had been stolen.
Rich Goldsmith11:53am
Sep 25
And to clarify, according a few lawyers I've spoken with, once Matthews gives away the signs, they're no longer his property -- even if he gives them away to someone who wasn't planning on putting them on a lawn. And if they were stolen from a lawn, then yes, of course it's a violation of property rights.

However, the point is, even if the signs were stolen, and assuming the accounts of the witnesses are true (and I would tend to think they are, given that a GOP member is corroborating them), we have a candidate for office who's perfectly content not to follow due process. Rather than tell the police the situation, he chose to take the law into his own hands and yank the mask off a peaceful protester's face -- then attempted to shirk the consequences by lying about it. Whether the signs are stolen property or not, the behavior is unacceptable from both a societal and a legal standpoint. And certainly verboten in anyone looking to represent us in D.C.

But as you say, this is a blog. A blog aimed squarely at firing back at the idiocy so prevalent in today's news and politics. Though I do take issue with your propagandist accusation. We sat on this story for nearly three weeks while we looked for credible witnesses to the incident. Were we simply interested in slander and propaganda, we would've happily fired away.
John MacArthur (not verified)05:18am
Oct 16
You are out of order. Your ideas are backwards. Even if a person suspected something was theirs, they cannot go and use force to take it. They would have to make the accusation first and have it settled by law. Even then, Mr. Ed Matthews would have a difficult time proving the sign was his, when political signs are as freely available as toilet paper in a public restroom. Ed Mathews was the criminal in this instance, along with the police officers, both of them assaulted this protester. I hope there is a lawsuit, they were all out of line. This is a person that wants to represent people? Give him a piece of your mind: www.edmatthewsforcongress.com
Rich Goldsmith10:47pm
Oct 19
O.J. learned this one the hard way.
Anonymous (not verified)03:08pm
Sep 26
I went to law school with Ed Matthews. At that time he was an ass and from the looks of things, nothing has changed. His politics notwithstanding, he seemed to be lacking in basic empathy and a little short in the ethics department. The rumor during school was that he cheated on his wife with one of our classmates our first year. For anyone else who has been to law school, you'll understand when I say he was one of those guys who would steal the book we all needed from the library because the class was graded according to a forced bell curve and his grades had to be the highest- regardless of how. I can definitely see him doing this and he should be ashamed of himself- but of course, he won't be. Unfortunately, I live in Chicago and will not get the pleasure of voting against him in the upcoming election.

Blogs

Sports

Baseball:
Warning Track Power by Alex Halsted
Sports:
On the Ball by Britt Robson

Society

Weather:
Dude Weather by Jimmy Gaines

A&E

Fiction:
Write Now! by Terry Faust

Retired

Hockey:
Spazz Dad by Todd Smith
Style:
Hook & Eye
Misc:
Is This News?
Fiction:
Yo, Ivanhoe by Brad Zellar
Food:
Consider the Egg by Stephanie March
Wine:
Beyond the Cask
Food:
Food Fight!
Media:
To the Slaughter
Misc:
Outrage by Staff
Food:
Chef's Table
Guest Commentary:
Just Passing Through
Humor:
Spazz Dad by Todd Smith
Cars:
Road Rake by Chris Birt
Commentary:
Read Menace by Tom Bartel
Society:
The Adventures of Melinda by Melinda Jacobs
Politics:
Defenestrator by Rich Goldsmith
Food:
Breaking Bread by Jeremy Iggers & Ann Bauer
Books:
Cracking Spines by Max Ross
Music:
Hear, Hear by Staff
Art:
The Vicious Circle by 6 Critics
Secrets:
Secrets of the Day by Kate Iverson
Theater:
Seen in the City by Staff
Film:
Talk About Talkies by Staff